Dateline NBC “Down the Basement Stairs” December 15 2023 Recap & Preview

What Happened to Annamarie Cochrane Rintala & Killer Cara Rintala?

Cara Rintala was sentenced to 12-14 years in prison by a Hampshire Superior Court Judge for the 2010 strangulation death of her wife, Annamarie Cochrane Rintala. This case, marked by its complexity and multiple trials, concluded with a sentencing that took into account the time Rintala has already served.

The crime occurred in the couple’s home in Granby, Massachusetts. Rintala’s actions following the murder, including attempts to alter the crime scene and mislead investigators, were highlighted by the prosecution as indicative of her character and premeditation. Despite being supported by numerous letters and her history of public service as an EMT and paramedic, Rintala’s defense arguments were overshadowed by the nature of the crime.

The prosecution initially sought a 15 to 17-year prison sentence. They emphasized the violence of the crime and the deliberate actions taken by Rintala post-crime, arguing that these actions provided insight into her character and the lack of impulsiveness in her actions.

The defense advocated for a sentence equivalent to the time already served, about 7 ½ years. They highlighted Rintala’s lack of a prior criminal record, her career in public service, and the numerous letters attesting to her character. The defense also emphasized Rintala’s role as a caretaker for her daughter.

The trial history is notable. The first two trials resulted in deadlocked juries, and a 2016 conviction for first-degree murder was later overturned on appeal in 2021. The case saw changes in defense representation over the years and involved intense legal battles.

In court, Judge Flannery acknowledged the irreversible loss experienced by Annamarie’s family, stating that no legal remedy could truly compensate for their loss. The sentence was ultimately set at 12-14 years, taking into account the time Rintala has already spent incarcerated.