Dateline NBC “Endgame” December 22 2023 Recap & Preview

What Happened to Shele Danishefsky Covlin & Killer Rod Covlin?

In December 2009, the Covlin family faced a tragedy that would ultimately lead to a high-profile murder case. Shele Danishefsky Covlin, a 47-year-old successful banker, was found lifeless in her bathtub in her Upper West Side, Manhattan apartment. Initially, her death was assumed to be an accident, possibly caused by a slip and fall.

However, suspicions began to arise, particularly among Shele’s family members, who found it hard to believe that such a vibrant and successful woman could meet such a grim fate by accident. As details unfolded, it became apparent that Shele’s relationship with her husband, Rod Covlin, had been deteriorating. Rod, 11 years her junior, had been involved in multiple affairs, which ultimately led Shele to file for divorce.

Despite the divorce proceedings, the situation was complicated. Shele had arranged for Rod to live across the hall from her apartment to ensure the ease of co-parenting their two children, Anna and Myles.

On the morning of December 31, 2009, Rod Covlin received a frantic call from their nine-year-old daughter Anna, who had discovered her mother’s lifeless body in the bathtub. Rod rushed to the scene and claimed to have found a horrifying sight, with Shele submerged in bloody water. He immediately called 911 and began performing CPR.

Emergency services arrived promptly but determined that Shele had been deceased for a significant amount of time before their arrival. Rod’s explanation for her death was that Shele had slipped and fallen in the bathroom, referencing a cabinet door that appeared to have been dislodged during the incident.

Due to Shele’s Orthodox Jewish faith and the initial belief of law enforcement that her death was accidental, she was quickly buried without an autopsy.

However, as grief gave way to suspicion within Shele’s family, they began to question the circumstances surrounding her death. A week after her burial, they received her death certificate, which listed the cause of death as “undetermined.” This development led them to push for an exhumation and a thorough autopsy.

The autopsy results were shocking and marked a turning point in the case. Shele was found to have a broken hyoid bone, typically associated with strangulation. Her manner of death was changed to “homicide.”

Despite these findings, it would take nearly five years for investigators to accumulate enough evidence to charge Rod Covlin with Shele’s murder. The case eventually went to trial in the winter of 2019, almost a decade after the tragic event.

Prosecutors presented a compelling case, suggesting that the crime scene had been staged. They relied on photographs taken on the morning of December 31, 2009, to demonstrate that certain elements didn’t align with Rod’s explanation of an accidental death. For instance, the claim that Shele had dislodged a cabinet door during the fall was scrutinized.

During the trial, Rod Covlin was portrayed as a psychologically and physically abusive individual who was motivated by financial gain, given his impending exclusion from Shele’s substantial will. Witnesses testified about his manipulative behavior and his turbulent relationship with Shele.

Ultimately, the jury found Rod Covlin guilty of the murder of Shele Covlin, and he was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Despite his conviction, he has consistently maintained his innocence, arguing that Shele’s death was indeed a tragic accident.

The case took another dramatic twist when their daughter, Anna Covlin, publicly expressed her belief in her father’s innocence. In a letter to the District Attorney, she challenged the verdict and claimed that her mother’s death was a terrible accident. She emphasized her father’s love and support for her and her brother.

As of now, Rod Covlin is serving his prison sentence at the Attica Correctional Facility in New York, where he remains eligible for parole in 2040.