Dateline NBC “The Day the Music Died” August 16 2024 Recap & Preview

On August 16, 2024, NBC’s “Dateline” will present a riveting episode titled “The Day the Music Died,” with Keith Morrison leading the investigation into a chilling murder case. The episode revisits the 2016 killing of prominent plastic surgeon Dr. Frank “Buddy” McCutcheon Jr., which shocked the Asheville, North Carolina community. Dr. McCutcheon, known for both his surgical expertise and musical talent, was found murdered in his home, and the investigation led to a surprising revelation about the perpetrator.

The episode promises new insights through never-before-seen police footage and exclusive interviews with those close to the case. It will delve into the circumstances leading up to McCutcheon’s death, including the significant financial troubles that plagued him and his wife, Brenda McCutcheon. The investigation revealed that Brenda, who was sentenced to life in prison, shot her husband in a fit of desperation, possibly driven by the mounting pressure of an embezzlement probe against them.

Viewers will hear from key figures involved in the case, including BCSO detectives John Ledford and Walt Thrower, prosecutor Meghan Lock, and Brenda McCutcheon’s defense attorneys. The episode also features interviews with McCutcheon’s family and law enforcement officials who were deeply involved in the case. Through these narratives, “Dateline” will explore how a seemingly perfect life unraveled into a tragic crime, shedding light on the personal and legal battles that ensued.

In addition to recounting the harrowing events, the episode reflects on the profound impact of McCutcheon’s death on his friends and family. As the investigation unfolded, the shocking details and the emotional aftermath of the case became evident, painting a portrait of a man whose life ended in tragedy under the weight of personal and professional turmoil.