48 Hours “A Death in the Stairwell” October 11 2025 Recap & Preview
On Saturday, October 11, 2025, 48 Hours returns with a dramatic new episode titled A Death in the Stairwell, airing at 10:00 PM ET/PT on CBS. Correspondent Peter Van Sant investigates a perplexing case out of New Haven, Indiana, where a woman is accused of murdering her husband after he is found fatally injured at the bottom of their staircase.
A Sudden Tragedy and a Shocking Accusation
Alison Davis says she woke up to find her husband, Kevin Davis, critically wounded at the foot of their stairs. She called for help, believing he had fallen. But police weren’t convinced. What initially appeared to be a tragic accident quickly turned into a homicide investigation when an autopsy raised serious questions about the nature of Kevin’s injuries.
Authorities concluded the trauma did not match a simple fall, and Alison soon found herself fighting a murder charge—despite her repeated claims of innocence.
Inside the Investigation
48 Hours takes viewers deep into the courtroom battle that followed, featuring exclusive interviews with key figures on both sides of the case. Interviewees include:
- James Krueger, police chief, who oversaw the initial investigation
- Tesa Helge, the lead prosecutor, who laid out the case against Alison
- Andrew Baldwin and Maxwell Wiley, Alison’s defense attorneys, who challenged the medical evidence and fought to clear her name
- Dr. Bill Smock, prosecution medical expert, who testified that the injuries were consistent with assault
- Dr. L.J. Dragovic, a neuropathologist and forensic pathologist for the defense, who disputed those findings
Alison’s father, Steve Krause, also speaks out, defending his daughter and sharing the emotional toll the case has taken on their family.
A Fight for the Truth
With forensic evidence at the center of the trial, the episode explores how science, interpretation, and human error can play a critical role in the justice system. A Death in the Stairwell raises questions about what really happened that night—and whether the right conclusion was reached.
Don’t miss this compelling new episode of 48 Hours, airing Saturday, October 11 on CBS. The episode will also be available for streaming the next day on Paramount+.
